Some pieces carry deep symbolism, like the controversial home run ball Barry Bonds hit to break Hank Aaron’s record of 755 home runs. Fashion designer Marc Ecko bought it, marked it with an asterisk, and donated it to Cooperstown, highlighting the controversy surrounding Bonds. Initially sold in 2008, it was auctioned again in 2019, this time for $282,900.
O.J. Simpson’s 1968 Heisman Trophy changed hands as part of a court-ordered sale in 1999 to satisfy civil suit damages. Actor Charlie Sheen profited when he sold Babe Ruth’s championship ring, which he bought in 1994, along with Ruth’s iconic contract transferring him from the Red Sox to the Yankees, which fetched an impressive $2.3 million at auction in 2017.
Some items capture unforgettable sports moments, such as the gloves Muhammad Ali wore for his legendary “phantom punch” knockout in 1965, sold in 2015. Hockey player Jim Craig offered memorabilia from his 1980 Olympic victory, although his gold medal didn’t meet the reserve price, while his mask sold for $137,000. Meanwhile, a piece of basketball history, the original rules penned by James Naismith, was bought by Kansas alumnus David Booth for $4 million in 2010.
The Honus Wagner baseball card remains a grail among collectors, once reaching a $3.12 million bid in 2016. Babe Ruth’s jersey, worn between 1928-30, broke records in 2019, selling for $5.6 million, surpassing a prior record set by another Ruth jersey.
Other coveted items include Kirk Gibson’s bat from his 1988 World Series homer, sold for $576,000 in 2010, and an early baseball document from the Knickerbocker club, auctioned to an anonymous buyer in 2016. Todd McFarlane, famed comic book creator, paid $3 million in 1999 for Mark McGwire’s final home run ball from his 1998 season. Additionally, the iconic 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle card fetched $2.88 million, with even higher estimates if a mint 10 copy ever surfaces.
Modern collectibles like a ticket from Michael Jordan’s NBA debut went for $33,000 in 2018, while a rare prototype putter gifted to Tiger Woods in 1997 sold for nearly $23,000. These auctions highlight how sports history remains both valuable and cherished, preserving legendary moments for those willing to invest in their legacy.
